Pop quiz, Madison. What’s better than shopping local? For 100 points: Shopping local from the comfort of your own home. Not only is it one of the best ways to support the local economy, butlocally-crafted gifts tend to wow during the holidays (a big win in our book).

To kickstart your holiday shopping, we’ve rounded up 16 products we love from local Etsy shops — some of which hold the coveted Star Seller badge that’s given to sellers who consistently earn 5-star reviews, ship orders on time, and provide great customer service, aka less holiday stress for you.

Psst — Some of these items may sell out quickly due to limited quantities. Click on the link to the Etsy seller's page to find something similar.

The cat lover in your life is sure to cherish this humorous t-shirt. | Photo via Etsy

🎁 Under $25

Gold and silver braided ring ($19) | This trendy ring is sure to earn compliments and make a statement. | Silver Canyon Jewelry

Custom peanut butter spoon ($20+) | This is the perfect stocking stuffer for the foodie in your life. | EOJ Studios

Rainbow burp cloth ($22) | Baby's first holiday? Snag this colorful burp cloth that's made of organic cotton. | Sunny Day Designs USA — Star Seller ⭐️

Grumpy cats calendar ($17.50) | Sail into 2023 with this hilariously cute grumpy cat calendar. | The Raccoon Society — Star Seller ⭐️

Cat yoga shirt ($14.27+) | Perfect for the cat lover, this funny shirt features cats doing yoga poses. | Enoch Design US — Star Seller ⭐️

Mermaid sprinkle mix ($10.99) | The baker in your life will love this whimsical sprinkle mix. | Beske Bakes Shop

🎁 $25-$50

"Indoorsy" crewneck sweatshirt ($32.99+) | This quirky sweatshirt is perfect for homebodies. | Pure Pop Shop — Star Seller ⭐️

Mushroom baby dress ($46+) | Gift your little one this adorable fungi-forward dress. | Kinder Sprouts — Star Seller ⭐️

Wood business card holder ($50) | For the friend that's always losing their business cards. Need we say more? | Inelastic Goods

Leather personalized charm bracelet ($38) | This trendy bracelet can be made with three color options and can be personalized with a custom message or charm. | Daintily Designs

For the loved one that can never have too much holiday decor. | Photo via Etsy

🎁 $50-$100+

USA cast iron skillet ($145) | Unique kitchenware is always a great gift in our books. This USA-shaped cast iron skillet is perfect for the chef in your life. | American Skillet Co.

Bottle brush rainbow trees ($79+) | These rainbow-hued Christmas trees are perfect for your festively trendy friend. | Your Hearts Content

Riveted steel fire pit with grill grate ($195) | It may be winter, but when has that ever stopped a Wisconsinite from firing up the grill? This fire pit would be a great addition to any outdoor space or tailgate. | Nomadic Grill — Star Seller ⭐️

Damascus kitchen knife ($88) | This knife doesn't just look cool, it's made of high carbon and high tensile steel that make it extremely sharp and durable too. | Titan International

Hand-cut layered paper sculpture ($750) | This unique and abstract paper sculpture has plenty of color and dimension — perfect for the art collector in your life. | CAB Fine Paperworks